This week, Donald Trump opened the private equity and cryptocurrency industry in trillions of dollars with new investments from US retirement savings, reshaping the financial future of 90mn Americans and turbocharges the growth of asset managers and digital currency groups.
However, the order that allows for 401k savings is a plan to invest in a variety of alternative assets, putting American retirees at new risk.
Following heavy lobbying by private capital groups such as Apollo Global Management and BlackRock, we see access to these retirement plans as a way to paint hundreds of billions of dollars of lucrative assets.
The measure is expected to open up retirement funds to new private investments, from corporate acquisitions and private loans to infrastructure transactions. In doing so, it potentially exposes them to higher rates and reduces transparency. Some of the $90 held in these 401K plans could be shepherded into assets that are more difficult to value and sell than traditional stocks and bonds that today make up the majority of retirement plans.
“We are pleased to announce that Sean McKey, global head of asset management for KPMG’s audit unit. “Many leaders will see this as a business model opportunity.”
Benjamin Schiffrin, director of securities policy at Better Markets, warned that the move was “bad” for 401K plan holders. “Retail investors will be exposed to a completely different type of assets without necessarily realizing it,” he said.
The acquisition group has struggled to sell trillions of dollars on investments and deliver returns to investors. This led to pension funds and donations retreat from the sector, blocking important sources of cash. Instead, large private capital groups such as Blackstone have hampered future growth in order to manage the savings of retirees and wealthy individuals.
Wall Street appears to persuade the 401ks manager to add funds as part of its investment program, allowing Trump to win with an order that should give the industry important political and legal coverage. Their campaign included heavy lobbying by Apollo, Carlisle and BlackRock, according to financial disclosures.
Other groups such as Blackstone have directed their efforts through industry associations.
Some of the industry’s most powerful leaders, including Apollo Head Mark Rowan, are publicly advocated on behalf of this effort.
In public, Rowan and his associates argue that 401k savers are missing out on the potential for diversification and high returns without access to the private market.
“We essentially utilized the country’s retirement system for Nvidia,” Rowan said in February about the high concentration of 401K savings in index funds dominated by a small number of tech stocks. This week he repeated his call to open the 401K market to private investment, saying it was “common sense.”
The Defined Contribution Alternative Association, an influential lobbying group used by many large PE groups, even argued that Washington would be sued for not providing a higher return on PE transactions, according to those who were described on the issue.
“The order has been “long postponed” as wealthy clients have access to the space for a long time,” said Harvey Schwartz, CEO of Carlisle.
BlackRock said the addition of private investment in retirement plans “ensures millions of Americans build stronger and more diverse portfolios.”
In the White House, Trump’s National Economic Council and Economic Advisory Council acted as people of the point between the private capital industry and the president, according to one official. Deputy Chief of Staff, Stephen Miller, helped draft the order.
One top advisor said the administration’s interest in cryptocurrency played a role in getting orders at the president’s desk, noting its popularity in the White House.
Trump praised the industry by making deregulation of digital assets at the heart of his administration and helping him win the 2024 presidential election. The Trump family-managed entity has recently invested billions in cryptocurrency.
Some people in the private equity industry were afraid that the order would link their funds to newer speculative cryptocurrencies, especially if the 401K plan suffered painful losses in digital asset investments. However, according to people familiar with their ideas, they viewed it as an acceptable trade-off.
There were no rules to explicitly rule out investment in alternatives, but the 401K manager was reluctant to invest in assets. Most people fear lawsuits from workers exposed to funds, due to the high costs and the high leverage that many strategies employ.
“These cases cost a lot. There are many settlements, but there are no valuable victory in the courts by (401K Planning Manager),” said Rajiv Chanda, partner at Simpson Soccer & Bartlett. The fear “had a huge, frightening effect on the merits of the claim,” he said.
Trump has directed the agency to make it easier for 401K plan managers to provide private investment. This has been added in part by adding provisions to curb lawsuits over private strategy.
Recommended
“The only special interest that will guide President Trump’s decision-making is in the greatest interest of Americans,” said Kush Desai, associate White House reporter.
“The President’s historic executive order presents his pledge to make America wealthy again by democratizing access to alternative asset classes that modernize and expand the daily American retirement investment options.”
Attention is now being directed at the Labor Bureau, overseeing and enforcing the 1974 law setting the standard for companies that provide 401K profits.
The asset manager is racing to prepare the 401K products for guidance from the Ministry of Labor that is expected within the next six months. Many have announced a partnership that provides private investment in targeted date funds. This partner will select assets for retirement that are planned in decades. These funds mix investments in publicly traded stocks and bonds with more opaque private assets.
Others offer more direct access to private investment, but require companies to provide access to advisors if 401K participants are aiming to invest.
Empower, the US’s second largest US retirement planning provider, said in May that it will partner with Apollo, Goldman Sachs Asset Management and Partners Group and others to provide access to private asset investments for its retirement plans.
A month later, BlackRock said it would offer 401k investment provider Great Gray Trust a target date fund that mixes public and private investments. Additionally, BlackRock is working on its own target-date funding, including private assets.
Other partnerships are also appearing. Blackstone has a “strategic alliance” with Vanguard and Wellington Management to create public-private funding for retirees, while KKR and Capital Group are exploring the creation of model portfolios and target date funding that span public-private arenas.
Michael Pedroni, a former Treasury official who currently runs the policy advisory group Highland Global, said that he is willing to pay how much US households will pay and access private assets.
“Now Americans are used to paying 30-50 basis points in 401ks. Let’s say that it’s up to 80 basis points. Would they be willing to pay that?”
Additional Reports by Amelia Pollard
